|
JESSICA'S
TAKE:
ADVICE SISTER JESSICAS TAKE:
I guess I will have to
call Advice Sister Alison "old fashioned" because it's
nearly the new millennium-and no one thinks twice about couples
living together who aren't married. While I agree that a "roommate"
isn't a husband, I have to say that for many reasons, couples who
DO have strong relationships but have CHOSEN not to get married
live together as a lot more than just "roommates." The
old saw about "why buy the cow if you already have the milk?"
doesn't fly with me. I think that commitment has little to do with
"holding out" these days..most couples DO have a sexual
relationship before they tie the knot. I also believe that living
together can be a great prelude to marriage when you are not "quite
sure" you are compatible or if the time isn't right financially
or for other reasons but a couple wants to be together or because
they don't WANT to make the commitment of marriage (there ARE legitimate
other kinds of commitment!). We know of a woman who "chose"
to live with her boyfriend even though he was DYING to marry her
because he had just gone through an awful divorce and she KNEW he
wasn't ready to be a husband again...even though she was besotted
with him. After a year of living with him, she had learned all his
bad habits and decided to bail." Marriage is a commitment
you need a legal proceeding to undo...but living with someone before
you get married does not: you can learn what you are dealing with
and what you are getting yourself into, and get "out"
if necessary.
The only reason I can
see NOT to move in is if you want marriage and nothing else will
do. As Advice Sister Alison says, making yourself "indispensable"
probably won't work. If he doesn't want marriage and you move in
hoping he will change his mind, you are more likely than not doomed
to serious disappointment when, after living with him, he still
won't "commit." Living together is a reasonable and legitimate
relationship choice...but not as a substitute for what you really
want if that is a ring on your finger.
|
|
ALISON'S
TAKE:
ADVICE SISTER ALISONS TAKE:
There are two schools of
thought on this. One, why buy the "cow" if you can have
the "milk?" In other words, once you move in all comfy and
cozy why should he marry you--especially if he is marriage shy? The
other school (what your friends are saying) is that once he "tries
you out" he won't be able to live without you. In
my view, the only reason to move in together is because you want to
be together in that kind of situation and it suits both of you. You
should NEVER agree to do this to "hook" your man! And you
shouldn't do it if it feels wrong to you and what you really want
is marriage and nothing less. In
large cities where apartments are scare and expensive, the "moving
in" issue is often accelerated by the expense of keeping two
apartments. If a couple is spending all their time together anyway
they might think: "Why
shouldn't we move in and save the rent? We might be able to pool resources
and get a better place? Call
me old fashioned, but a ROOMMATE isn't a husband. If you move in with
no strings attached (like getting engaged first) you are likely to
spend a lot of years without hearing those wedding bells. If you don't
care about that, get packing and have a wonderful life with your live-in
guy!
|